The top 10 in this list, model by model
1 · About average
Bentley Bentayga
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.10, 95% CI 0.07–0.15), from 8,888 MOT tests at 3 to 7 years: 0.3% of its tests had a brake fail, against 2.5% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 1–5.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at a large SUV; the ones tested were 76% petrol, 22% diesel.
2 · About average
Audi e-tron
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.13, 95% CI 0.10–0.16), from 38,725 MOT tests at 3 to 6 years: 0.2% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.8% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 1–5.
Check before you buy: fails on tyres 1.4–1.5× as often as cars the same age (2,749 fails in 38,725 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted).
Suits: buyers looking at a large SUV; the ones tested were mostly electric.
3 · About average
BMW M5
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.14, 95% CI 0.10–0.18), from 5,997 MOT tests at 8 to 11 years: 0.8% of its tests had a brake fail, against 5.8% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 1–6.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at an executive car; the ones tested were mostly petrol.
4 · 86% fewer brake MOT fails
Lexus UX
Why it ranks here: 86% fewer brake MOT fails than cars the same age (ratio 0.14, 95% CI 0.12–0.17), from 39,686 MOT tests at 3 to 6 years: 0.3% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.9% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 1–6.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at a family SUV; the ones tested were mostly hybrid.
5 · About average
Volkswagen e-Golf
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.19, 95% CI 0.16–0.24), from 23,394 MOT tests at 3 to 6 years: 0.4% of its tests had a brake fail, against 2.1% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 3–10.
Check before you buy: fails on tyres 1.8–1.9× as often as cars the same age (2,153 fails in 23,394 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted); fails on suspension 1.3–1.6× as often as cars the same age (400 fails in 23,394 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted).
Suits: buyers looking at a family hatchback; the ones tested were mostly electric.
6 · About average
Lexus ES
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.21, 95% CI 0.15–0.29), from 9,727 MOT tests at 3 to 5 years: 0.4% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.8% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 1–16.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at an executive car; the ones tested were mostly hybrid.
7 · 77% fewer brake MOT fails
Volkswagen ID.3
Why it ranks here: 77% fewer brake MOT fails than cars the same age (ratio 0.23, 95% CI 0.20–0.27), from 45,442 MOT tests at 3 to 5 years: 0.4% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.7% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 5–13.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at a family hatchback; the ones tested were mostly electric.
8 · About average
Porsche Taycan
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.25, 95% CI 0.20–0.31), from 19,618 MOT tests at 3 to 5 years: 0.4% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.7% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 5–16.
Check before you buy: no part fails significantly more often than on cars the same age (ages 3 to 15).
Suits: buyers looking at an executive car; the ones tested were mostly electric.
9 · 75% fewer brake MOT fails
Jaguar I-Pace
Why it ranks here: 75% fewer brake MOT fails than cars the same age (ratio 0.25, 95% CI 0.22–0.28), from 57,577 MOT tests at 3 to 6 years: 0.5% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.9% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 5–13.
Check before you buy: fails on number plates and VIN 1.7–2.2× as often as cars the same age (239 fails in 57,577 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted).
Suits: buyers looking at a family SUV; the ones tested were mostly electric.
10 · About average
Mercedes-Benz EQC
Why it ranks here: No clear difference from cars the same age by our 20% rule (ratio 0.25, 95% CI 0.20–0.31), from 22,290 MOT tests at 3 to 5 years: 0.4% of its tests had a brake fail, against 1.7% for all cars at the same ages (not mileage-adjusted). Rank range 5–16.
Check before you buy: fails on tyres 2.4–2.5× as often as cars the same age (2,637 fails in 22,290 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted); fails on suspension 2.4–2.9× as often as cars the same age (401 fails in 22,290 MOT tests at ages 3 to 15, not mileage-adjusted).
Suits: buyers looking at a family SUV; the ones tested were mostly electric.
How we rank
96,645,911 MOT tests from 2022–2025 of cars 3 to 15 years old. For each model and age, the share of tests with at least one brake fail (brakes (discs, pads, pipes, hoses, the parking brake and brake performance)) is compared with all cars of that age: the expected count is the model's tests times the all-car share. The ratio of the two sets the order. This list is not adjusted for mileage (the DVSA data has no mileage split by part) or for test year.
The 95% intervals cover sampling error only (Wilson intervals). A model is called fewer or more only when its interval is at least 20% from the all-car rate, overall and at 3 or more ages; awards use the same rule. How we compare
Limitation: mileage drives part wear, and this list cannot allow for it, so it is a guide to what fails, not a ranking of build quality. MOT tests record roadworthiness defects on the test day, not breakdowns or repair costs, and only cars still on the road are tested.