Common problems by part
Smart Forfour (before 2014) brakes problems
DVSA MOT tests 2022–2025 · 2,974 MOT tests · Updated
At 18 years, 12.7 in 100 MOT tests of the Smart Forfour (before 2014) failed on brakes, against 12.9 for all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years; 2,974 MOT tests) [1].
Buying Report £14.99 incl. VAT · one car · no subscription · Not a mechanical inspection.
- Against all class 4 vehicles the same age: about average for all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years), 379 MOT tests with a fail
- By age: seen at 5 ages from 16 to 20 years, 10,940 MOT tests
- Most common fail: Handbrake too weak, 3.8 per 100 MOT tests
Figures are for the model as a whole, not for one car.
What the MOT tests show
What we know
12.7 fails per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 12.9 for all class 4 vehicles tested at 18 (all test years). That is about average.
Why it matters
A brakes fail stops the car passing until it is fixed; the most common one is rated major by DVSA.
What to check
Look through the wheels at the discs for a deep lip or heavy scoring, and check the brake pipes under the car for flaky rust. On the drive the car should stop straight with no pull or judder.
Smart Forfour (before 2014) brakes fails by age
| Age | MOT tests | Fails per 100 | All class 4 vehicles the same age |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | 1,536 | 10.6 | 11.6 |
| 17 | 2,914 | 11.6 | 12.3 |
| 18 | 2,974 | 12.7 | 12.9 |
| 19* | 2,333 | 12.0 | 13.3 |
| 20* | 1,183 | 11.2 | 13.5 |
All first-use years of the Smart Forfour (before 2014) pooled at each age, against all class 4 vehicles at that age over all 2022–2025 test years. * Only survivors are still tested at this age.
What fails in the brakes at 18 years
Fails
- Handbrake too weak: 3.8 fails per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 2.8. Parking brake efficiency below requirements MOT fail
- Brake pads under 1.5 mm: 2.8 fails per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 1.8. Replace brake pads: estimated £72–£174 (0.6–1.2 h at £78/h (ONS local-garage repair quotes, 1,058 quotes from 65 garages, Sep 2025 to Aug 2026) + parts £25–£80) Brake pad(s) less than 1.5 mm thick MOT fail
- Parking brake performance: inoperative on one side: 2.2 fails per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 1.2. Parking brake inoperative on one side MOT fail
- Service brake imbalance: across an axle: 1.6 fails per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 0.7. Service brake imbalance across an axle MOT fail
Advisories (not fails)
- Brake discs: worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened: 14.5 advisories per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 11.1. Brake disc worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened MOT advisory
- Brake pads: wearing thin: 8.7 advisories per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 6.4. Brake pad(s) wearing thin MOT advisory
- Brake discs: worn, but not excessively: 3.3 advisories per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 2.1. Brake disc worn, but not excessively MOT advisory
- Rigid brake pipes: corroded, covered in grease or other material: 3.1 advisories per 100 MOT tests, all class 4 vehicles 12.3. Brake pipe corroded, covered in grease or other material MOT advisory
Replace brake discs and pads cost
Repair figures are estimates, not quotes: how we estimate repair costs.
Buying a Smart Forfour? Check that exact car before the viewing.
Buying Report £14.99 incl. VAT · one car · no subscription · Not a mechanical inspection.
- Model risks for this year and fuel
- What similar cars did at their next MOT
- Repairs ahead
- Viewing checklist
How to check on a test drive
Look through the wheels at the discs for a deep lip or heavy scoring, and check the brake pipes under the car for flaky rust. On the drive the car should stop straight with no pull or judder.
The most common advisory here in MOT records: Brake discs: worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened.
Check one Smart Forfour (before 2014), not the average
The figures here describe Smart Forfour (before 2014) cars as a group. These free tools answer for one car. Each line says what the tool reads.
- Check a Smart Forfour (before 2014)'s MOT history Every MOT test, fail item, advisory and mileage reading DVSA holds for that registration.
- MOT advisory checker Paste an advisory or defect to read DVSA's wording, its grade and what tends to happen at the next MOT.
Other Smart Forfour (before 2014) problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) suspension problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) lights and electrics problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) steering problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) body and structure problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) exhaust, emissions and leaks problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) seat belts and airbags problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) windscreen, wipers and mirrors problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) tyres problems
- Smart Forfour (before 2014) road wheels problems
Brakes on rival models
- Peugeot 107 brakes problems: 15.4 per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 12.7 for the Smart Forfour (before 2014) (18,721 MOT tests)
- Toyota Aygo brakes problems: 15.1 per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 12.7 for the Smart Forfour (before 2014) (17,860 MOT tests)
- Fiat Panda brakes problems: 15.0 per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 12.7 for the Smart Forfour (before 2014) (15,201 MOT tests)
Questions people ask
Does the Smart Forfour (before 2014) have more brakes problems than other cars?
12.7 in 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 12.9 for all class 4 vehicles the same age: about average by our test (all test years; 2,974 MOT tests).
How common are Smart Forfour (before 2014) brakes problems?
12.7 in 100 MOT tests at 18 years failed on brakes, against 12.9 for all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years; 2,974 MOT tests).
What is the most common Smart Forfour (before 2014) brakes fail?
3.8 in 100 MOT tests at 18 years: Handbrake too weak (114 MOT tests with it).
Sources
- Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency, Anonymised MOT tests and results, 2022 to 2025. DVSA MOT data, Open Government Licence v3.0, 10,940 MOT tests. Accessed 7 Oct 2026.
- Office for National Statistics, Consumer price inflation, local price quotes (car repair items). ONS price quotes, series 610236. Accessed 7 Oct 2026.
Parts: against all class 4 vehicles at the same age, all 2022–2025 test years pooled, not adjusted for mileage. Breakdowns and non-MOT faults are not in this data. How we compare