Subaru Legacy common problems: what fails and which years to choose
DVSA MOT tests 2022–2025 · 16,488 MOT tests · Updated
37.7% of Subaru Legacy MOT tests at 18 years ended in a fail (at typical mileage), against 44.1% for all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year (2,231 MOT tests) [1].
Buying Report £14.99 incl. VAT · one car · no subscription · Not a mechanical inspection.
First used 2009: 5.8 pts fewer fails than all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year at ages 13–16, 1,692 MOT tests
Exhaust, emissions and leaks: fails 1.5–1.8× as often as all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years), 251 MOT tests with a fail at 18
Lights and electrics: 18.3 fails per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 21.4 for all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years; 2,268 MOT tests)
Which engine and year a car has decides which of these apply. Check the reg first.
These are figures for the model as a whole, not for one car.
At 18 years, the same age and test year
Is the Subaru Legacy reliable by MOT data? Lower MOT fail rate than average
38.9% raw · 37.7% at typical mileage, against 44.1% for all class 4 vehicles tested at 18 in the same test years, over the same mileage bands (2,231 MOT tests).
13 DVSA recalls for this model.
Even so, 38.9% of Subaru Legacy cars failed at 18 years. Which one you're looking at decides it.
Here reliability is measured as MOT failure rate at the same age and mileage, not breakdowns.
Which Subaru Legacy years have fewer MOT fails
Each first-use year against all class 4 vehicles tested at the same age in the same test year, over the ages it was seen at in the 2022–2025 MOT tests (raw rates, not adjusted for mileage). A badge needs a 95% interval that excludes zero, a gap of at least 2 points and 8% of the baseline, and either a clear difference from an adjacent first-use year or an adjacent year with the same badge (a run of years). "About average": the interval stays within 2 points; "Not clear": the tests or the adjacent years do not settle it.
Percentage points against all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year (raw rates, not adjusted for mileage). More failsFewer failsNo badge
First used
Ages seen
MOT tests
Against all class 4 vehicles the same age
Badge
2005
17–20
2,417
−8.0 pts to −2.5 pts
Fewer fails than average
2006
16–19
2,640
−6.2 pts to −1.4 pts
Not clear
Show all 9 years
First used
Ages seen
MOT tests
Against all class 4 vehicles the same age
Badge
2004
18–21
1,971
−6.2 pts to −2.9 pts
Fewer fails than average
2007
15–18
1,915
−9.1 pts to −3.0 pts
Fewer fails than average
2008
14–17
1,571
−4.8 pts to −0.8 pts
Not clear
2009
13–16
1,692
−7.0 pts to −3.0 pts
Fewer fails than average
2010
12–15
1,884
−7.0 pts to −2.7 pts
Fewer fails than average
2011
11–14
1,847
−5.4 pts to −2.3 pts
Fewer fails than average
2012
10–13
1,062
−6.4 pts to +2.0 pts
Fewer fails than average
Buying a Subaru Legacy? Check that exact car before the viewing.
Buying Report £14.99 incl. VAT · one car · no subscription · Not a mechanical inspection.
"all class 4 vehicles the same age" means all class 4 vehicles (cars and vans together) tested at the age named, here all class 4 vehicles tested at 18. Each part area is compared with them over all 2022–2025 test years pooled, not adjusted for mileage. A card needs a 95% interval clear of 1.2 times at 18 years and the same at three or more ages up to 18 years, each with at least 100 MOT tests with a fail.
Exhaust, emissions and leaks
CommonExhaust, emissions and leaks fails 1.5–1.8× as often as all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years).
11.1 fails per 100 MOT tests at 18 years, against 6.8 for all class 4 vehicles tested at 18 (2,268 MOT tests).
What fails
Malfunction indicator lamp: inoperative or indicates a malfunction: 5.4 per 100 (all class 4 vehicles 2.5)
Catalyst emissions: Lambda reading after 2nd fast idle outside specified limits: 3.5 per 100 (all class 4 vehicles 1.3)
Catalyst emissions: carbon monoxide content after 2nd fast idle exceeds manufacturer's specified limits: 1.1 per 100 (all class 4 vehicles 0.6)
Most common advisory
Engine oil leaks: leak, but not excessive
Cost
Diagnose engine warning light cost: Estimated £39–£78 (0.5–1 h at £78/h (ONS local-garage repair quotes, 1,058 quotes from 65 garages, Sep 2025 to Aug 2026) + parts)
about average for all class 4 vehicles the same age
129
Seat belts and airbags
1.1
2.7
about average for all class 4 vehicles the same age
24
Steering
1.0
3.9
about average for all class 4 vehicles the same age
22
Road wheels
0.4
0.5
about average for all class 4 vehicles the same age
8
From 2,268 MOT tests at 18 years, against all class 4 vehicles tested at 18 over all 2022–2025 test years pooled, not adjusted for mileage.
Most common advisories and what they lead to
Consecutive MOT tests of the same car 10 to 17 months apart: Subaru Legacy at 16-25 years.
Advisory
Failed on the same part at the next MOT
With no advisory
MOT tests with the advisory
Suspension arms
10.9%
3.7%
1,280
Tread depth
3.5%
1.1%
986
Brake discs
2.9%
0.5%
696
Brake pads
7.2%
2.6%
655
Sub-frame
2.1%
0.7%
624
What to check when viewing a Subaru Legacy
Exhaust, emissions and leaks: Engine oil leaks: leak, but not excessive; Start the car from cold and look for smoke at the exhaust, listen for blowing joints, and look under the engine and gearbox for fresh oil or fluid drips.
Questions for the seller
Ask for the last two MOT certificates and read the advisories for exhaust, emissions and leaks.
Ask what was repaired after the last MOT, and for the invoices.
Ask how the car has been used: short trips, towing, taxi or fleet work.
Ask for proof recall R/2019/052 was done.
Ask for proof recall R/2019/025 was done.
Ask for proof recall R/2018/346 was done.
Don't buy a Subaru Legacy without checking if:
it was advised for suspension arms (16-25 years: 10.9% failed next MOT, 3.7% without)
it was advised for tread depth (16-25 years: 3.5% failed next MOT, 1.1% without)
it was advised for brake discs (16-25 years: 2.9% failed next MOT, 0.5% without)
it was advised for brake pads (16-25 years: 7.2% failed next MOT, 2.6% without)
it was advised for sub-frame (16-25 years: 2.1% failed next MOT, 0.7% without)
it was advised for exhaust system (16-25 years: 11.9% failed next MOT, 3.0% without)
From consecutive MOT tests of the Subaru Legacy. Check the car’s own MOT record for these advisories before the viewing.
Check one Subaru Legacy, not the average
The figures here describe Subaru Legacy cars as a group. A registration shows one car's own DVSA record: its MOT tests, the mileage at each test and the recall flag.
37.7% of Subaru Legacy MOT tests at 18 years ended in a fail at typical mileage, against 44.1% for all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year (2,231 MOT tests). Reliability here is measured as MOT failure rate at the same age and mileage, not breakdowns.
Which Subaru Legacy years have the fewest MOT fails?
9 first-use years compared and 7 stand out against all class 4 vehicles the same age (16,999 MOT tests). 2009 had the fewest fails (−5.8 pts).
What is the most common problem with the Subaru Legacy?
18.3 in 100 MOT tests at 18 years failed on lights and electrics, the most common MOT fail on the Subaru Legacy, against 21.4 for all class 4 vehicles the same age (all test years; 2,268 MOT tests). Breakdowns and faults an MOT does not test are not in this data.
2005 Subaru Legacy problems: what do the MOT tests show?
2,417 MOT tests of Subaru Legacy cars first used in 2005, at ages 17–20: −5.6 pts against all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year (95% interval −7.5 pts to −3.7 pts, raw rates).
2004 Subaru Legacy problems: what do the MOT tests show?
1,971 MOT tests of Subaru Legacy cars first used in 2004, at ages 18–21: −4.6 pts against all class 4 vehicles the same age and test year (95% interval −6.7 pts to −2.4 pts, raw rates).
The verdict compares the Subaru Legacy at 18 years with all class 4 vehicles at the same age and test year, adjusted to typical mileage. Years: each first-use year against all class 4 vehicles at the same age and test year, raw rates, not adjusted for mileage. Parts: against all class 4 vehicles at the same age, all 2022–2025 test years pooled, not adjusted for mileage. Breakdowns and non-MOT faults are not in this data. How we compare